The fine line between leadership and control: How to know you’ve crossed it

Navigating the line between leadership and control can be tricky business.

When you’re leading, you’re guiding others towards a common goal. But the moment you cross over to control, you’re dictating how things should be done.

It’s like walking a tightrope, always at risk of overstepping your role. But don’t fret – there are signs that tell you when you’ve crossed that fine line.

So let’s dive right in. Here’s how to recognize when your leadership might be verging on control.

1) Micromanaging is your go-to strategy

In the realm of leadership and control, one of the biggest red flags is micromanagement.

As a leader, your job is to guide and inspire your team towards a common goal. However, when you start dictating every single step they should take, you’ve crossed over into the territory of control.

Micromanagement isn’t just about being overly involved in the minutiae of tasks. It’s about not trusting your team to handle their responsibilities. It sends a message that their skills and judgement aren’t valued.

Recognizing this tendency can be tricky. After all, it’s often disguised as ‘attention to detail’ or ‘ensuring quality’. However, if you find yourself unable to let your team make any decision without your input, it might be time to reassess your leadership style.

Remember, leadership is about empowering others, not controlling them. So if you’re falling into the habit of micromanagement, take a step back and re-evaluate.

2) You’re reluctant to delegate

In my early days as a team leader, I was convinced that to ensure things got done right, I had to do them myself. This is a common pitfall that many new leaders fall into, and it’s a sure sign of crossing from leadership into control.

I remember once, while working on a crucial project, I found myself buried under a pile of tasks. Despite having a capable team that could have shared the load, I hesitated to delegate.

The result? I was burned out and the project suffered. It wasn’t until a mentor pointed out my reluctance to delegate that I realized my mistake.

True leadership means trusting your team with responsibilities. If you’re like me and find yourself hoarding tasks, it may be time to loosen the reins and allow your team to shine. It’s not easy, but learning to delegate is an essential step towards becoming an effective leader.

3) Communication is one-way

In a survey conducted by the American Management Association, over 70% of employees listed lack of open communication as a prime cause of low morale. This demonstrates the importance of two-way communication in leadership.

If you’re doing all the talking and leaving no room for input or feedback from your team, then you’ve crossed the boundary from leadership to control. Leadership involves listening and valuing the opinions of those around you.

A one-way flow of communication creates a divide between you and your team, making them feel unheard and undervalued. In contrast, fostering an environment where everyone feels comfortable expressing their ideas promotes trust and cooperation.

Remember, good leaders don’t just lead, they listen.

4) You’re resistant to change

Adaptability is a cornerstone of effective leadership. As a leader, you should be open to new ideas and be willing to adapt your strategies as situations change.

But if you find yourself resisting any changes to your plans or methods, then you might be veering more towards control than leadership.

Being rigid and inflexible can stifle innovation and prevent your team from exploring new opportunities. It can also create unnecessary tension and conflict within your team.

So, if you’re clinging to ‘how things have always been done’, take a moment to reflect. Are you leading or controlling?

An essential part of leadership is fostering growth and embracing change, not just for yourself but for your entire team.

5) Fear is the driving force

If your team members are constantly anxious or afraid to make mistakes, it’s a clear sign you’ve crossed from leadership into control.

As a leader, your goal should be to inspire and motivate, not intimidate. A work environment driven by fear can lead to low morale, high stress, and reduced productivity.

Instead of ruling with an iron fist, aim to create a culture where mistakes are viewed as opportunities for learning and growth.

Remember, leadership is not about instilling fear but about fostering trust and respect. If fear is the driving force behind your team’s actions, it’s time to reassess your leadership style.

6) You forget the human element

At the end of the day, it’s important to remember that your team is made up of humans, not machines. Each person has their unique strengths, weaknesses, emotions, and life outside of work.

If you see your team members only as tools to accomplish tasks, you’ve tipped over from leadership to control.

True leaders don’t just manage their team’s work; they care about their team’s well-being. They recognize and appreciate their team’s efforts, celebrate their successes, and support them through challenges.

So take a moment to connect on a personal level with your team. A little empathy can go a long way in turning a controlling environment into one of leadership and mutual respect.

7) You’re always in problem-solving mode

Early in my career, I believed that as a leader, it was my duty to solve every problem that came up. I thought that’s what leadership was about. But over time, I learned that I was wrong.

Leadership isn’t about having all the answers; it’s about guiding your team to find solutions together. If you’re always jumping in to ‘save the day’, you’re not leading – you’re controlling.

This was a tough lesson for me. I had to learn to step back and trust my team’s abilities. It wasn’t easy, but once I did, I saw my team’s confidence and problem-solving skills grow exponentially.

So if you find yourself constantly in problem-solving mode, pause and ask yourself: Are you leading or just fixing? True leaders empower their teams to solve problems, they don’t do all the work themselves.

8) Feedback is a one-way street

Feedback is a vital part of any team’s growth and development. But if it’s only flowing in one direction – from you to your team – then you’ve strayed into control territory.

Effective leaders not only provide constructive feedback but also seek and value feedback from their team. They understand that they’re not perfect and see feedback as an opportunity to learn, grow, and improve.

But if you’re resistant to receiving feedback or dismissive of it, you’re not just controlling but also shutting off a valuable source of learning.

Remember, leadership is a journey of continuous learning and improvement. Being open to feedback from your team can provide insights that make you a better leader.

9) Trust is lacking

At the heart of leadership is trust. If trust is lacking in your team, this is the biggest sign that you’ve crossed from leadership into control.

Trust is the bedrock of any successful team. It fosters open communication, boosts morale, and encourages collaboration. But most importantly, it allows for growth and innovation.

If your actions are undermining trust – whether it’s through constant oversight, lack of transparency, or dismissing input – then you’re not leading, you’re controlling.

Building and maintaining trust may take time and effort, but it’s worth every bit of it. A team that trusts its leader is a team that can achieve great things.

Final thoughts: It comes down to respect

Navigating the fine line between leadership and control often boils down to a single, powerful concept – respect.

Respect for your team’s abilities, their ideas, and their autonomy forms the foundation of true leadership. And fostering this respect can make all the difference.

As the renowned leadership expert, Ken Blanchard, once said, “The key to successful leadership today is influence, not authority.”

If you find yourself veering towards control rather than leadership, remember this. Reflect on your actions and attitudes. Are they fostering respect and trust, or are they undermining it?

Leading is not about exerting control but about inspiring trust and respect. It’s about guiding your team to become better versions of themselves.

So as you go forward, remember to lead with respect. Because a leader who respects their team is a leader who truly leads.

Picture of Graeme


Enhance your experience of Ideapod and join Tribe, our community of free thinkers and seekers.

Related articles

Most read articles

Get our articles

Ideapod news, articles, and resources, sent straight to your inbox every month.