9 signs someone is not really a good person (even if they seem nice on the surface)

Alright, let’s be honest – we’ve all encountered those people who seem like absolute angels on the surface, but leave you with a nagging feeling that something’s not quite right.

They might flash a dazzling smile and shower you with compliments, but their actions often tell a different story.

It’s time to ditch the rose-colored glasses and get real about the subtle signs that someone might not be as good as they seem.

We’re talking about those sneaky behaviors, the passive-aggressive comments, and the blatant disregard for others that reveal their true colors.

So, let’s dive in and explore nine telltale signs that someone might not be the saint they pretend to be.

Get ready to sharpen your instincts and protect yourself from those who might not have your best interests at heart.

1) They’re consistently unreliable

Everyone has moments when they drop the ball.

Life happens, and sometimes we can’t follow through on promises. But when someone is consistently unreliable, it may be a sign they’re not as good as they seem.

Being unreliable doesn’t just mean they occasionally forget to show up for a lunch date. It’s a pattern of behavior that shows a lack of respect for other people’s time and feelings.

If you find yourself constantly disappointed by their broken promises or last-minute cancellations, it might be time to reassess how ‘good’ this person truly is.

A genuinely good person values the time and feelings of others, and they strive to fulfill their commitments.

So, the next time someone leaves you hanging for the umpteenth time, keep this in mind – their actions speak louder than their surface-level charm.

2) They often take more than they give

Here’s a personal example. I once had a friend, let’s call her Linda.

Linda was all smiles and charm on the outside, always the life of the party. But over time, I noticed that our relationship was heavily one-sided.

Whenever we’d go out, she’d somehow forget her wallet and I’d end up footing the bill.

She’d borrow things and ‘forget’ to return them. When I needed help or support, suddenly she was too busy or just unavailable.

In short, Linda was always willing to take but rarely inclined to give anything in return. This imbalance was draining and left me feeling used.

Good people understand the balance of give and take in any relationship. They don’t exploit others for their own benefit.

If you notice someone consistently taking more than they’re giving – be it time, resources, or emotional support – it could be a red flag that they’re not as good as they first appear.

3) They’re quick to judge others

Did you know that psychologists say we form a first impression within a tenth of a second? That’s faster than the blink of an eye!

Now, forming quick judgments isn’t inherently bad – it’s part of human nature.

But when someone is constantly casting harsh or negative judgments on others, that’s a different story.

Truly good people strive to understand others, rather than judge them hastily. They know that everyone has their own story, their own struggles, and their own strengths.

They try to see the good in people, rather than focusing on flaws and weaknesses.

Ultimately, if someone is always criticizing and judging others negatively, without attempting to understand or empathize, it might be a sign that they’re not really as good as they seem on the surface.

4) They’re frequently unkind to service staff

Ever been out with someone who was sweet as pie to you, but turned into a nightmare when interacting with the waiter or cashier? That’s a huge red flag.

How people treat those in service roles can reveal a lot about their character. Good people understand that everyone deserves respect, regardless of their job or status.

They know that kindness isn’t selective; it should be extended to all.

If someone is habitually rude or disrespectful to service staff, it might be a sign that they’re not really as good as they seem on the surface.

After all, kindness isn’t about who it’s convenient to be kind to; it’s about being kind, period.

5) They often play the victim

Playing the victim 10 signs youre in a relationship with a covert manipulator 9 signs someone is not really a good person (even if they seem nice on the surface)

No one’s life is free of hardships and setbacks.

But if someone constantly portrays themselves as the victim, it might be a sign they’re not as good as they seem.

People who habitually play the victim often refuse to take responsibility for their actions.

Everything is always someone else’s fault.

They thrive on sympathy and attention, often manipulating others to get it.

Good people, on the other hand, own up to their mistakes and learn from them.

They understand that life isn’t always fair, but they don’t use that as an excuse to shirk responsibility or manipulate others.

So if you know someone who always seems to be the victim of circumstances, consider this a red flag. It might be time to take a closer look beneath that nice exterior.

6) They lack empathy

Empathy is the ability to understand and share the feelings of others. It’s a cornerstone of being a good person.

But not everyone who appears nice on the surface truly possesses this quality.

I’ve encountered people who were quite charming, but when it came down to showing genuine concern for others, they fell short.

They could talk a good game, but their actions (or lack thereof) revealed a surprising lack of empathy.

It’s heartbreaking, because empathy is what connects us as human beings.

It allows us to support each other, to understand different perspectives, and to help those less fortunate.

If you notice someone consistently failing to show empathy – whether it’s disregarding your feelings or showing indifference to others’ struggles – it’s a strong sign they’re not as good as they appear.

True goodness goes deeper than surface-level niceness; it involves the capacity to truly care for others.

7) They’re dishonest

Dishonesty is a trait that’s hard to overlook. I remember a time when I worked with someone who seemed to have all the makings of a great colleague.

They were charismatic, hardworking, and seemingly nice.

But over time, I discovered they had a habit of twisting the truth.

Little white lies turned into bigger deceptions.

They would take credit for others’ work, spread rumors, and even lie about their own accomplishments.

It was disheartening to realize that this seemingly ‘good’ person was actually quite deceptive.

Honesty is a fundamental quality of good people.

They understand that trust, once broken, is hard to regain.

If you find yourself dealing with someone who often bends the truth or outright lies, it’s a strong sign they may not be as good as they seem on the surface.

8) They hold grudges

We’re all human, and we all make mistakes.

Good people understand this and are often quick to forgive.

They don’t hold onto resentment or let past wrongs fester into grudges.

However, if you encounter someone who seems unable to let go of past slights, even minor ones, it could be a sign they’re not truly good.

Holding a grudge is more than just being unforgiving – it’s allowing negativity to take hold and influence current and future interactions.

Good people strive to resolve issues, forgive when they can, and move forward without harboring resentment.

So, if someone is always holding grudges, it might be worth taking a closer look beneath their pleasant exterior.

9) They lack respect for boundaries

The most important thing to remember is this: good people respect boundaries.

They understand that everyone has their own personal space, physically and emotionally, and they respect it.

If someone constantly oversteps your boundaries, ignores your comfort levels or dismisses your concerns, it’s a glaring sign they’re not as good as they seem.

Disregarding boundaries is a fundamental lack of respect for you as an individual.

True goodness isn’t just about being nice on the surface.

It’s about respecting others, their feelings, and their boundaries.

Conclusion

So, while it’s true that first impressions can be deceiving, it’s equally important to pay attention to these subtle behavioral clues.

They might just reveal the cracks in that seemingly perfect facade.

Remember, being a ‘good person’ isn’t about grand gestures or performative acts of kindness.

It’s about consistency, empathy, respect, and a genuine desire to uplift those around you.

If someone consistently displays these red flags, it might be time to reassess their place in your life.

After all, you deserve to surround yourself with people who truly reflect the goodness they project.

Picture of Ava Sinclair

Ava Sinclair

Ava Sinclair is a former competitive athlete who transitioned into the world of wellness and mindfulness. Her journey through the highs and lows of competitive sports has given her a unique perspective on resilience and mental toughness. Ava’s writing reflects her belief in the power of small, daily habits to create lasting change.

Enhance your experience of Ideapod and join Tribe, our community of free thinkers and seekers.

Related articles

Most read articles

Get our articles

Ideapod news, articles, and resources, sent straight to your inbox every month.

0:00
0:00